In today's complex and dynamic business landscape, effective corporate governance is paramount to the long-term success and sustainability of companies. Central to this governance framework is the practice of shareholder engagement, wherein boards actively interact with shareholders to understand their perspectives, address concerns and align corporate decisions with shareholder interests. This article explores the multifaceted reasons why boards need to conduct shareholder engagement and the significant benefits it brings to corporate governance.

Understanding Shareholder Perspectives

Shareholder engagement serves as a direct conduit for boards to tap into the insights, concerns and priorities of their shareholders. By engaging directly with shareholders, boards gain a nuanced understanding of investor expectations, governance preferences and areas of focus. This deep understanding enables boards to make informed decisions that reflect shareholder interests, thereby enhancing shareholder value and fostering long-term shareholder loyalty.

Addressing Shareholder Concerns

Shareholder engagement provides boards with a platform to address shareholder concerns, questions and feedback in a timely and constructive manner. By actively listening to shareholder perspectives and responding effectively to their inquiries and criticisms, boards demonstrate responsiveness and accountability. This proactive approach helps mitigate potential sources of conflict or dissatisfaction, thereby strengthening the company's reputation and investor relations.

Accounting for ISS Impacts

Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) holds a position as a leading provider of proxy voting and corporate governance solutions. Boards of directors play a pivotal role in overseeing the company's governance practices and engaging with shareholders, making understanding of ISS policies and impacting shareholder voting outcomes imperative. Although certain policies ISS has adopted may not align with a company’s culture or strategy, it is important for directors to understand these policies to address any potentially negative reactions that may come from not following ISS guidelines.

ISS policies range from board composition and independence, director elections, executive compensation program structure, shareholder rights and many other governance issues. ISS will provide shareholders with voting guidance related to directors or other issues up for vote. Their policies can be extensive and tend to focus on executive compensation.

Proxy Voting and Say-on-Pay

Shareholder engagement is instrumental in proxy voting and say-on-pay processes, enabling boards to communicate directly with shareholders about critical matters such as executive compensation practices and governance proposals. By engaging with shareholders ahead of proxy votes, boards can address concerns, explain their rationale and seek support for their proposals. This proactive engagement enhances shareholder participation and ensures that corporate decisions reflect shareholder input and interests.

It is also an opportunity to address ISS voting guidance and explain the rationale behind any divergence that exists — a significant step within this process.

Informing Strategic Decision-Making

Shareholder engagement plays a pivotal role in informing strategic decision-making by providing boards with valuable input and feedback on key issues. From executive compensation and capital allocation to mergers and acquisitions and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations, shareholder engagement ensures that corporate strategies and initiatives are aligned with shareholder interests and expectations. This alignment fosters sustainable growth and value creation, driving long-term shareholder value.

Make no mistake, shareholder and advisory firms should not dictate decisions. Giving them a platform to voice concerns or share ideas is healthy, but allowing them to dictate board decisions can set a bad precedent.

Stakeholder Management

Shareholder engagement is an integral part of stakeholder management, aimed at building positive relationships with investors, employees, customers, communities, and others. By engaging proactively and transparently with shareholders, boards demonstrate a commitment to responsible stewardship and sustainable value creation, enhancing the company's reputation, resilience, and overall stakeholder trust, driving long-term success.

However, it is important to use shareholder engagement time wisely. While all shareholders are important, focus should be on larger shareholders, especially those with voting flexibility. Many large investors have inflexible policies that dictate their votes or require adherence to ISS recommendations. Therefore, prioritize efforts on shareholders who can be influenced and vote according to their preferences. Shareholder engagement enables boards to gain valuable insights, enhance transparency, address concerns, inform decision-making, facilitate proxy voting and manage stakeholder relationships effectively. By embracing shareholder engagement as a strategic imperative, boards can demonstrate their commitment to shareholder value and contribute to the company's long-term success and sustainability.

Connect with an Expert

No matter what compensation challenges your company is facing right now, our team is here to help you make informed, strategic pay decisions so you can effectively attract, retain and reward top talent. 

Connect with one of our compensation experts today so we can start helping you achieve your business goals.